Guidelines from the American Psychological Association states, “traditional masculinity – marked by stoicism, competitiveness, dominance and aggression – is, on the whole, harmful”. Essentially a ‘boys will be boys’ mentality is toxic. Creating a world where bullying and sexual predation is unacceptable is worthy of everyone’s time and attention. Certainly, parents must sort through the implications of how to raise up boys into the next generation of men. So, what are we to think? Are we to believe that a boy’s rough nature, competitive spirit, and high energy are to be seen as defective attributes? In this nature/nurture discussion, how do you raise your son to fulfill his potential and also protect him from a society that views his emerging masculinity as toxic?

There is a difference, in our view, between masculinity and manliness. They certainly overlap. However, our thought is that masculinity is biological, whereas manliness is sociological. As parents, we intend to raise our boys into men and not just bigger males. It seems to us that society, and certainly the APA, isn’t making this formative distinction. Of course, domineering qualities are disdainful, and violent actions are instances of a troubled individual. But to say masculinity itself is a problem is to throw the boy out with the dirty bathwater. Raising your sons into men of character who are comfortable with their masculinity is an enormous advantage to them, a blessing to their future wife, and a wellspring of benefit to society.

There has been a decades-long effort to eradicate competition in sports. The notion that everyone should be a winner misses the point. The idea that “Competition leaves so many losers and causes harm to developing self-esteem and isn’t the message we should be sending our children”. Not so. The noble circumstance of losing at something is an opportunity of either getting better or choosing another venue to try one’s hand. Eliminating competitive events robs children of the common outcome of losing to someone who is better…at that event! The competitive spirit feeds into the ego and is one of the main forces that has propelled mankind throughout history. (Male competence is also a main factor in female mate selection.) Losing is a huge character builder. Parents should counsel their children to “stick with it”, “practice”, “learn to deal with adversity”, and “be strong of character”. Don’t wish it were easier, work on being better. That’s what competition should do for boys (and girls by the way).

Stoicism is the idea that trouble, pain, emotions, and difficulty are endured without outward expression. Supposedly stoicism is included in the idea of toxic masculinity under the notion that bottled up emotions eventually lead to an explosion, some sort of destructive behavior that causes harm. Ok, that could be true for anyone, male or female. Life is difficult and proper contextualizing of life’s circumstances takes guidance. That’s what parents do. Parenting helps model proper actions and brings articulation to the child’s understanding. Parents certainly need to know their child’s heart and be ever observant of changes in mood and behavior. In so doing, they can be available to help guide the resolution of internal conflict; not remove the conflict but be a guide. Being stoic doesn’t mean being bottled up. It means having the internal fortitude to withstand difficulties without unnecessary complaining. 

There is no clear line where positive male traits tip over into excessive qualities, no more than there is a clear distinction of female qualities, like manipulation that leads to bullying. Each gender has its own innate qualities that must be harnessed with mature guidance into useful traits for life. The notion that innate masculine qualities themselves are toxic is absurd, versus the idea that an immature man hasn’t developed the character to display self-controlled behavior. 

This OneFamily letter took a detour into current affairs because of our perception that this idea of toxic masculinity is itself toxic. Raising up men in a toxic world starts with the idea that they are fearfully and wonderfully made and designed by a loving God with perfect qualities. Yet, it’s like the story of the man who was tending his bountiful garden. A priest comes by and sees this abundance and comments “My friend, you have truly been blessed by God.” The gardener sees where the preacher was going with this and replies, “Yes, truly I have. God has been good. But you should have seen it when God had it all to himself.”

Boys must be tended.

Many blessings,

Lis and Dave